He wanted to do things with her that he hadn’t with anyone else. Things he’d only fantasized about before.
Which was how she ended up over his knee before the Oriole’s game they were meeting everyone at.
“I’m supposed to go to the game with a plug in my butt?” she whined as he pressed the lubricated tip to her virgin hole. Whether or not he’d ever get his cock in the tight orifice, he wasn’t sure, but he knew he wanted to play with it. The first time he’d put his finger there while eating her out, she’d nearly kicked him in the head from surprise — so he’d tied her in place and continued doing what he was doing, but it had made the area much more tantalizing a target.
“That’s right.” He pushed in slightly, feeling the resistance, enjoying the little noise of surprise and uncertainty that she made. “It’ll help remind you to be a good girl while we’re out in public. Plus, it will be fun.”
“I think you and I have very different ideas of fun,” she grumbled, making Ethan laugh. He pushed the plug in deeper and Ria squealed.
“I think your problem is that we have exactly the same idea of what constitutes ‘fun’ and sometimes you wish we didn’t.”
He’d hit a little too close to home with that observation. Fortunately, he didn’t seem to expect a response as he pulled the plug back a bit before pushing it in deeper still and making her moan and wriggle as her backside was invaded. Ria had written about plugs and butt stuff plenty of times, but this first experience… it was more invasive, more humiliating, and more arousing than she’d imagined.
Her pussy fluttered as it pushed in, opening her up, stretching her entrance with a raw sensation as the toy rubbed against her nerve endings, causing a fluttering that was indescribable. It felt so wrong and so good at the same time. Her brain was insisting it was an ‘out’ hole, and yet her pussy clenched at the sensation of being filled there. Or maybe it was the idea of taking his cock there, because of course she was now wildly curious as to what that would feel like.
How much it would hurt.
How good it would feel.
“Ow!” She squealed as the thickest part pushed past her tight ring. She could actually feel her entrance snap into place around the little neck between the bulb and the flat base.
“Good girl,” Ethan crooned, twisting it inside her.
The amount of lube meant it spun easily, despite the way her muscles clamped down around it, which was the oddest sensation. Ria moaned, shuddering a little.
“You look very pretty with a plug in your ass, princess.”
